Who’s behind this review? Buena Vida is a running app made by David Cole, a Seattle runner & triathlete who led design and research for Amazon’s Halo fitness band. Every plan here, including Buena Vida’s, is scored on the same 30 measures, each tied to published research. AI does the first scoring and draft, then every claim is checked against its studies. No plan author pays to be reviewed, and we run no ads. See a mistake? Email David at corrections@buenavida.run · How we score →
This marathon plan from Runner's World is a 16-week build for a first marathon, written for runners who already run 3 or 4 times a week and have about a year of running behind them. For them, it's a simple route to the finish: 5 mostly conversational runs a week and a long run that builds to 20 miles.
Before he founded the magazine, Bob Anderson was a Kansas high-school runner with a beginner's question. "I sent out a letter that said I was 17 and I wanted to run a marathon but I didn't know how to train," he later recalled. This plan is the magazine's answer to that question.
The catch is that the running climbs in sudden steps, the first clearly lighter weeks don't come until the taper, and strength training never makes it onto the schedule. A runner who has been hurt recently, or has less running behind them than the plan assumes, would be better served by a plan that builds more gently.
Flawed
| Structure | 3 | |
| Prevention | 3 | |
| Flexibility | 3 | |
| Readiness | 3 | |
| Variety | 3 |
There are no separate phases. For 13 weeks, the weekly running and the long run climb together. Then the last 3 weeks step down to race day. Almost all of it is easy running. Weekly running starts at 16 miles and peaks at 44 in week 13, the week of the only 20-miler.
The long run moves in a sawtooth: a new longest run one weekend, a shorter one the next, and so on up to 20 miles. Wednesday grows into a second, mid-length run of 8 miles from week 8, and 10 in week 13. In week 7, you can race a half marathon in place of the 14-mile long run.
It's for runners who already run 3 or 4 days a week and have been running for about a year.
A week on the Runner's World plan
Here is week 9, one of the plan's bigger steps up.
MONDAY is a rest day. Ideally you don't exercise at all, though something easy and low impact, like swimming or yoga, is allowed.
TUESDAY is an easy 4 miles.
WEDNESDAY is an easy 8 miles, the week's mid-length run.
THURSDAY is an easy 4 miles.
FRIDAY is rest.
SATURDAY is an easy 3 miles, kept gentle to save your energy for Sunday.
SUNDAY is the long run, 16 miles, the farthest yet.
That's 5 runs and 35 miles, 6 more than the week before. All of it is conversational. Any of the shorter runs can become the same amount of time on a bike, an elliptical or in the pool.
Sunday is the run the week is built around. It's 2 miles past anything you've covered, and it comes a week after a 10-miler. The plan's own advice is to take it slowly, walk if you need to, and use the time to learn what keeps your head in it for that long: company, music, a phrase to repeat.
But the week is decided on Tuesday. The tip printed on that day says to make sure your easy days are easy enough, and suggests running with a slower friend or on an easy trail to make sure of it. A Tuesday that drifts a little quick turns Wednesday's 8 miles into work. A Thursday that does the same leaves Sunday's 16 starting on legs that are already tired. Run the short days slower than feels necessary, and save the effort for the long one.
Watch your shins the week after. The tip on the following Tuesday is about shin splints, which tend to show up after mileage climbs without enough rest. The plan's advice there is sound: if you feel them coming on, back off and check your training log.
Does it build you up smartly?
A good marathon build has a shape. The running grows a little at a time, and what the training asks of you changes from one block of weeks to the next, turning toward the race itself near the end. Shifting the emphasis that way tends to beat holding one kind of training the whole way through.
This plan has the climb, but not the blocks. Volume and the long run grow for 13 weeks, while the kind of running never changes, the phases are never named, and the last weeks of the build look like the first ones, only longer. Every run is a plain distance, so there's never a question about what a day asks of you. For a first marathon, keeping the running easy is a sound choice. Triple Olympic champion Peter Snell, who later became an exercise physiologist, called his approach "a relatively simple formula" and put it this way: "Develop endurance as early as possible." The body's first job is to learn to cover the distance, and the week 4 tip has it right that your first 10-miler may be a run you always remember.
Does it protect you from injury?
Partly. The plan protects you well from day to day, but the way it builds from week to week leaves a newer runner exposed.
Start with what it gets right. There are 2 rest days every week, always on Monday and Friday, and an early tip explains why rest matters: you won't lose fitness from a day off, and rest helps you avoid overuse injuries. With the running kept easy, there are no hard days to stack on top of each other.
The trouble is the steps up. Sudden jumps in running tend to raise the risk of getting hurt, most clearly when a single run goes well past your longest of the past month. Each new longest run here is only 2 miles past the last, but the plan takes 6 of those steps, and 4 weeks grow by more than a fifth. The biggest is week 13. The 20-miler arrives, and the weekdays swell around it: Tuesday nearly doubles to 7 miles, Wednesday reaches 10, and the week ends 7 miles bigger than any before it.
That matters most for the runner this plan is written for. Your blood and muscle energy systems tend to adapt within a few weeks, while tendons need weeks to a few months and bone takes longer still. Olympic marathon medalist Lorraine Moller puts it as a rule: "you can never progress faster than your slowest part will allow." After a year of running, you can feel ready for week 13 well before your shins and feet are. The plan seems to know the pull: in week 12, it reminds you that you'll probably feel strong enough to add miles, and asks you to stop at 15 anyway. Running coach Jenny Hadfield gave a first-timer who wanted to go past 20 miles the same advice: "Avoid adding mileage out of fear as it will increase your risk for injury and you may end up leaving your best running on the training path." The job in a first marathon build is to keep showing up, not to be a hero in one week.
The build also rarely lets up. The long run steps back most other weekends, and the plan calls week 12 a cutback. Yet the weekday runs keep growing, so those weeks are only a few miles lighter than the ones before them. The first clearly lighter weeks are the 2 just before race week. Training that piles up with no relief tends to raise the risk of injury and illness, and a plan you follow on your own needs that relief written in, which coaches usually place every 3 to 5 weeks. Across 13 weeks of climbing, this plan offers almost none.
Strength is the other gap. A week 4 tip nudges you toward the weight room, and a taper tip asks you to keep strength work going, but no session ever appears on the schedule. Finding the days and building the sessions falls to you. And it's worth finding them, because strength training lowers the risk of sport injuries substantially.
The plan's injury advice is useful but scattered: shin splints on one Tuesday, blisters on a Thursday, rest days and the IT band on another. Its best line is the shin splint one, to check your log and back off a bit. An Irish club runner described that first twinge to injury researchers this way: "you have planted the little injury seed… the injury is on its way." A lingering low-grade ache may raise the risk of a full injury, though that has been measured in footballers rather than runners, so that habit deserves to be a rule for every ache, not a tip for one.
What happens when you miss a day?
Missed runs are part of any 16-week build. A plan earns its keep by telling you what to do next.
This one handles a bad day well. Runs are set by feel rather than by a pace on a watch, so an off day just means running slower. Barry Smyth, a researcher who studies marathoners' training data, gives new runners a simple check: "If you can't string a few words together then you are probably going too fast." On an off day, that check is the only one this plan asks you to pass. Any of the shorter runs can become cross-training, and a week 12 tip says walk breaks help when you're coming off a break or having an off day.
But for bigger disruptions, the plan has little to say. It doesn't say which run to protect in a short week. The long run is the obvious one to keep, but it's left for you to work out. And there's no rule for a lost week: repeat it, skip ahead, or trim the long run. With a new longest run waiting most other weekends, getting that call wrong carries more risk here than in a plan that builds gently.
Will it get you ready for race day?
A marathon is mostly a test of whether your legs can keep going for a long time. Coaches build marathon plans around a growing long run, and runners whose training includes longer long runs tend to finish faster, though that is an association and no one has tested whether shorter, faster sessions could do the same.
For a runner whose goal is to finish, this plan covers the essentials. The long run reaches 20 miles in week 13, 3 weeks before race day, and the plan treats that run as a dress rehearsal: the same shoes, the same clothes, the same start time as the race if you can manage it. The biggest week, 44 miles, suits a first marathon well. Then the last 2 weeks before race week step down, and a taper of up to 3 weeks improves race performance compared with not tapering. By week 15, the final long run is 8 miles, a distance that once felt like a stretch.
The week 7 option to race a half marathon is a generous touch. You get to practice the start, the crowd, and holding back when everyone around you goes out fast. Coaches widely recommend a tune-up race, and it may help as pacing rehearsal, though no study has tested what it does for the marathon itself. Coach and author Matt Fitzgerald puts it simply: "Like any other skill, pacing requires repetition. No runner gets their pacing right the first time." The week 7 half gives you that first try before race day. And if you already have a half behind you before you start, one study of first-time marathoners linked that experience with fewer injuries during training.
But there's little practice at race effort. Apart from the optional half and a final 8-mile long run that builds toward race pace, every mile is easy. For finishing, that's a fair trade. If you have a finish time in mind, this plan gives you little to build it with.
Are the workouts varied enough?
Enough for a first marathon, with one clear gap: nothing on the schedule ever asks your legs to move quickly.
Easy running makes up most of a runner's weekly miles, and it's the base everything else rests on. This plan is built almost entirely from it, in different lengths: short weekday runs, a growing Wednesday, a long Sunday. And within about 8 weeks of steady running, the same easy pace tends to come with a lower heart rate. A watch that reads heart rate is often the first place it shows.
But a year into running, a little variety goes a long way, and this plan offers almost none. There are no strides, no hills on the schedule, and no drills. Tips in weeks 5 and 13 suggest hillier routes, but nothing is planned around them. Strides, a handful of short, relaxed bursts at the end of an easy run, would cost a few minutes and give your legs regular practice at moving quickly.
The good & bad of training from a printable PDF
The plan is a printable PDF on the Runner's World website, offered to Runner's World+ members. It opens with an introduction on who the plan is for, followed by a week-by-week grid and a key to the workouts. Most running days carry a short tip, on everything from shoes and running form to blisters and race-week logistics. Many of them are good. The race-day advice, to start at the back and run the first miles slower than you think you should, is exactly what a first-timer needs to hear.
But a PDF is fixed once it's printed. The weeks are numbered, so lining week 16 up with your race date is your job. If a cold costs you a week, the grid stays as it was, and reworking the weeks after it is up to you. And the advice arrives one tip at a time, on the day it's printed. The tip on walk breaks after time off sits on a Saturday in week 12, whether or not that's the week you come back from one.
Is it right for you?
Run it. That's the starting point the plan is written for, and its easy running suits a first marathon.
Run it. Runs here are set by conversation, not by numbers on a watch.
Look elsewhere. The weeks that step up the most, with no strength work on the schedule, land hardest on those tissues.
Look elsewhere. The plan is written for runners with about a year of running and 3 or 4 runs a week behind them.
Think it over. Apart from one optional half and the last long run, there's no faster running, so it builds endurance but little speed.
Think it over. The plan asks for 3 weekday runs, and one of them grows to 10 miles.
A good alternative with an app
If a mostly easy plan built around the long run appeals to you, Buena Vida offers its members a first marathon plan of the same length, with the same 20-mile long run 3 weeks before race day. It starts close to where the Runner's World plan does, at about 17 miles a week.
Closest matchWhy this plan scores higher
- A lighter week every fourth week of the build, so the running never piles up for long without a break
- A strength session on your calendar every Monday of the build, a day with no run
- Weekly running that climbs in steps of a fifth or less, apart from the return after each lighter week
- Short, relaxed strides on an easy day most weeks, plus a hill session, so your legs get regular practice at moving quickly
- A note on nearly every run that says what it's for and how hard it should feel
What the app adds
- No complicated lookup tables. Each day's workout is clear and easy to follow
- Paces worked out from your own fitness, and adjusted automatically as you get stronger
- Miss a run, move a run, and the plan carries on
- Voice coaching through every workout, and runs recorded from your iPhone, Apple Watch, or Garmin
Get more out of your running with Buena Vida
Buena Vida was built by a runner to bring the whole job of training into one place: a plan that fits your schedule and your fitness, coaching on every run, and food targets that keep up with the work you do. Members get personal training & nutrition plans, plus full access to the catalog of pre-written plans for every running goal.
In research studies, runners on plans fit to them improved as much as or more than runners on fixed plans, and fewer of them stalled.
Try it FREE for 7 days. After that, it's $99.99 a year or $14.99 a month, and you can cancel anytime.
More plans like this
Each of these plans takes its own route to race day. Effort-based plans, like the Buena Vida plan above, set your hard sessions by feel, so you learn what 10K effort and tempo feel like, and your training paces grow with you as you get stronger. Time-goal plans set every pace from the finish time you're aiming for. Others trade days, weeks, or mileage to fit your life.
Frequently asked questions
- Is the Runner's World beginner marathon plan good for first-time marathoners?
- Yes, if you already run 3 or 4 days a week and have been running for about a year, which is who the plan is written for. If you're newer than that, a plan that starts lower and builds more gently is a safer place to begin.
- How many days a week does the Runner's World beginner marathon plan run?
- 5. You run on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Saturday and Sunday, and rest on Monday and Friday. Any of the shorter runs can be swapped for cross-training.
- How long is the longest run in the Runner's World beginner marathon plan?
- 20 miles, in week 13, 3 weeks before race day. The plan treats it as a dress rehearsal for the marathon.
- What does LSD mean in the Runner's World plan?
- Long slow distance. It's the weekend long run, done at an easy pace, slower than your shorter runs during the week.
- Can I race a half marathon during the Runner's World beginner marathon plan?
- Yes. In week 7, the plan lets you race a half marathon in place of the 14-mile long run, as practice for race day.
- Does the Runner's World beginner marathon plan include strength training?
- No. Tips in the plan encourage it, but no strength session appears on the schedule. Fitting it in is up to you.
- Does the Runner's World beginner marathon plan have recovery weeks or a taper?
- Only a light version before the taper. The shorter long runs and the week 12 cutback trim just a few miles from the week. The real step down comes in the 2 weeks before race week.
Research notes
- Shifting training emphasis beats unchanging training
- Sharp running-load jumps raise injury risk
- The body adapts on a staggered clock
- Fixed plans need built-in lighter weeks
- Strength training lowers injury risk
- Niggles often warn of a bigger injury
- Longer long runs go with faster marathons
- A real taper sharpens you for race day
- Tune-up races: untested, may help pacing
- A half marathon first may help new marathoners
- Easy miles do most of the work
- Your heart rate drops at the same pace
