Running Plan Review Higdon Marathon: Novice 2
By Hal Higdon's Marathon: The Ultimate Training Guide — Hal Higdon Requires purchase Visit plan website
Plan at a Glance
Novice 2 takes you one step up from Novice 1. Do it only if you have been running more than a few months, maybe with some racing experience. The long run mileage is slightly higher, with pace runs on some Wednesdays.
The review below is Buena Vida's full assessment of the plan. We grade every plan against the same detailed, 31-point benchmark. Each measure draws from peer-reviewed sports-science research and proven coaching best practices.
Workouts
Similar plans
Our Review
What separates Hal Higdon's Novice 2 marathon plan from his more famous Novice 1 is a single weekly addition: a marathon-pace run on most Wednesdays. Everything else stays the same shape. Four runs a week, a Saturday long run climbing to 20 miles, a cross-training day, and two days fully off. The pace run is the upgrade you are paying for.
That Wednesday run is the day to study. It starts at 5 miles in week 1 and grows to 8 by week 10, run at the exact pace you mean to hold on race day. For a first-timer that goal pace is conservative, so the run will not feel hard. The trap is treating it as filler. It is the one place in the build where you rehearse race rhythm and lock goal effort into your legs. Run it at a steady, even clip, not by mood, and you reach week 18 with a pace your body already knows. Skip the discipline and you reach mile 20 guessing, the same spot Novice 1 leaves you.
This is a step up from a true first-timer plan, built for someone who has run for a few months and may have a short race behind them. The schedule is the lean calendar. The depth sits in Higdon's book Marathon: The Ultimate Training Guide, which carries the effort cues, the nutrition, and two full chapters on staying injury-free. Read together they are the product. If you have never run 8 miles or held four weekly runs, start with Novice 1 instead. If you want a sharp time goal off speed work, his Advanced programs will serve you better, since nothing here runs faster than goal pace.
-
Structure
Does the plan build you up smartly?
The eighteen weeks have a clear build-then-ease shape, even though the grid never names a phase. Easy weekday runs, a growing Saturday long run, and a Wednesday marathon-pace run carry the work forward together. The longest run lands three weeks out, and the final stretch steps down in plain stages. A lighter week shows up roughly every third week to let your legs catch up. What the page leaves out is the why behind any run. A day reads "6-mile pace" and nothing more, so how hard to go and what each run trains both live in the book rather than on the calendar.
-
Prevention
Does the plan protect you from injury?
Your weekly mileage tops out near 40 miles, a fair ceiling for a first marathon, and a lighter step-back week lands about every third week so load rarely piles up. Behind the calendar, Higdon's book backs this with two injury chapters that name overtraining warning signs and walk you through prevention and water-based rehab. The rough edge is how fast a few weeks climb. The Saturday long run leaps several miles at once, like the 9 to 14 mile lift into week 7, and no single jump is reckless. But if a week feels heavy in the legs, repeating it before you climb again is the safer call than pushing through.
-
Flexibility
What happens when you miss a day?
Bending this plan around a busy week is mostly your judgment. The grid does flag the long run as the day to protect, but no rule on the page tells you what to drop when a cold or a deadline lands. The upside is built-in slack. Two full rest days and a cross-training day mean you can shuffle a run without falling behind. The grid sets no order for what to skip first and no make-up routine after a missed run. Once the long run is safe, every other trade is yours to weigh.
-
Readiness
Will the plan deliver race-day fitness?
This is where Novice 2 pulls ahead of the entry plan. The long run climbs steadily to 20 miles three weeks out, most of the marathon distance and enough to carry a beginner to the line. On top of that, the Wednesday pace runs let you rehearse goal effort eleven times across the build, so race pace is no longer a stranger on the day. The week-8 half marathon then lets you stress-test that drilled pace against a real field and a clock. Two limits remain. The long run stops at 20 miles, so the final 6.2 are fresh ground, and the pace runs name marathon effort without ever printing the seconds-per-mile you are chasing.
-
Variety
Are the workouts varied enough?
Three run shapes share the week here: short easy weekday runs, a long Saturday run, and a Wednesday run at marathon pace. That pace run is the variety Novice 1 never offers, and it gives the week a second texture beyond plain easy miles. Still, there are no intervals, no tempo surges, and no faster-than-goal work anywhere in the eighteen weeks. For a beginner chasing a first finish, that restraint is the point and keeps the plan simple to follow. A runner who likes mixing hard formats will find the rotation thin, with the week-8 half marathon as the only real change of gear.
Plan Strengths
- Eleven Wednesday runs at marathon effort, growing from 5 miles to 8, are the upgrade Novice 1 lacks entirely. By race morning the goal clip is a groove your legs have rehearsed, not a guess you test for the first time at mile 1.
- By week 15 you reach a 20-mile long run that lands three weeks out, so your legs are fresh and the distance feels familiar when it counts.
- Two full rest days and a cross-training day build in slack, so you can move a run around a job and a life without losing the thread.
- Week 8 drops in a half marathon, the one day that tests under real start-line pressure whether the goal pace you drill each Wednesday actually holds. It is also where you practice fueling on the move.
- About every third week the long run shrinks and the easy days lighten. That planned breather keeps the steady drip of Wednesday pace miles from stacking up faster than you recover.
- Reading the schedule takes no decoding. You see at a glance what to run each day, with one distance and a clear label and nothing more.
Weaknesses & gaps
- Goal pace still needs converting into seconds per mile, and that table sits in Higdon's book rather than beside the Wednesday pace run on your calendar.
- Watch the climb out of a lighter week: the next week can leap well past 10 percent as the long run jumps several miles in one step.
- You build the strength routine yourself. Higdon suggests Tuesdays but never writes a session onto the schedule, so the days and the moves are your call.
- Miss a run and the plan gives you no rule on the page for what to drop or how to make it up. The call to skip or stack is yours, under pressure.
- Your longest run tops out at 20 miles, so the final 6.2 of race day stay untested ground.
- Nothing ever runs faster than goal pace, so if your aim is a sharp time rather than a finish, the plan has no gear for it.
What this plan does not give you
The first thing you will sort out yourself is the actual number behind "pace." The Wednesday runs name marathon pace but list no splits, so you will need Higdon's book to turn a goal finish time into seconds per mile before week 1. Strength work is the next gap. He suggests Tuesdays but never writes a session onto the grid, so a short routine twice a week is yours to set and schedule. The plan also skips how hard to run each easy day; "easy" means you can still talk, and that cue lives in the book. Finally, there is no rule on the page for a missed run. The safest move is to skip it rather than cram two days together, and never stack the long run onto a hard day to catch up.
What the science supports
Long runs are essential for marathon
The Saturday long run is the spine of this plan. It opens at 8 miles in week 1 and climbs, with lighter weeks mixed in, to a peak of 20 miles in week 15 before the taper. Research is clear that a marathon needs these progressive long runs and that no amount of shorter, faster work can stand in for them. The slow buildup is what teaches your legs to keep going deep into the race.
Toresdahl et al. 2021; Jones & Kirby 2025; Casado et al. 2019
Race-pace specificity hinges on physiology
Novice 2 adds a marathon-pace run on most Wednesdays, growing from 5 miles to 8. Running at your goal pace builds the motor pattern and pacing feel for race day. One honest note from the research: for a beginner, goal pace usually sits well below a hard physiological effort, so these runs help mostly by rehearsing rhythm rather than by sharpening top-end fitness. They are practice, not a speed engine.
Pierce et al. 1990; Hewson & Hopkins 1996; Jones et al. 2021
Easy aerobic volume is the foundation
Most of the week is easy running. The short weekday runs of 3 to 5 miles and the 60-minute cross-training day are meant to stay relaxed, not pushed. That easy aerobic volume is the base of the whole pyramid in the research: it is the foundation that lets the harder long runs and pace runs actually do their job. The plan asks you to hold back on these days so the key sessions can land.
Haugen et al. 2022; Casado et al. 2022; Tønnessen et al. 2014
Tune-up races sharpen pacing skill
A half marathon drops into week 8, right in the middle of the build. Studies link prior race experience to better marathon pacing, and the value comes from rehearsing how to hold an even effort under real pressure, not from the fitness it adds. Treat it as a dress run for race morning: start slower than feels natural, practice your fueling, and notice what the back half teaches you about the full 26.2 to come.
Tapering improves race performance by 2-6%
The last three weeks step down on purpose. After the 20-mile long run in week 15, the long runs shrink to 12, then 8, then a 2-mile shake-out, while the weekday runs shorten too. A structured taper of one to three weeks is shown to lift race performance by a few percent compared with training right up to the day. The cutback here lets the work you banked surface as fresh legs on the start line.
Train better with Buena Vida
Buena Vida Run Club members get access to a catalog of 250 training plans as part of their membership. Training with Buena Vida offers detailed daily workout notes, integrated nutrition, live voice coaching, weight loss plans, and easy calendar management for life's hiccups.
Try it FREE for 7 days!
Frequently asked questions
- Is Higdon Marathon: Novice 2 good for beginners?
- Yes. Higdon Marathon: Novice 2 is designed for runners new to the distance.
- How many days per week does Higdon Marathon: Novice 2 require?
- The plan runs on a schedule of multiple weekly runs. See the at-a-glance strip for the exact count.
- Does Higdon Marathon: Novice 2 include a taper?
- Yes, the plan includes a taper into race week.
- What is the rubric grade for Higdon Marathon: Novice 2?
- Higdon Marathon: Novice 2 grades C on the Buena Vida rubric.